by
Bill Bonner
The Dow is still rising. It rose another 125 points yesterday… hitting a new record high.
Gold is dawdling.
We’re
still thinking about how so many smart people came to believe things
that aren’t true. Krugman, Stiglitz, Friedman, Bernanke — all seem to
have a simpleton’s view of how the world works. They believe they can
manipulate the future and make it better. Not just for themselves, but
for everyone. Where did such a silly idea come from?
Aristotelian
logic came to dominate Western thought after the Renaissance. It was
essentially a forerunner of positivism — which is supposedly based on
objective conditions and scientific reasoning. “Give me the facts,” says
the positivist, confidently. “Let me apply my rational brain to them. I
will come up with a solution!”
This is fine, if you are building
the Eiffel Tower or organizing the next church supper. But positivism
falls apart when it is applied to schemes that go beyond the reach of
the “herald’s cry.”
That’s what Aristotle said. He thought only a
small community could work at all. Because only in a small community
would all the people share more or less the same information and
interests. In a large community, you can’t know things in the same
direct, personal way. So it’s hard for people to work together in the
same way.
In a large community, you have no idea who made your
sausage or what they put in it. You have to rely on “facts” that are no
longer verifiable by direct observation or personal acquaintance.
Instead,
the central planners’ facts usually are nothing more than statistical
mush, wishful thinking or theoretical claptrap — like Weapons of Mass
Destruction, the unemployment rate and the Übermensch.
Large-scale planning fails because the facts upon which it is built are unreliable, frequently completely bogus.
And it fails because people don’t really want it.
Hidden Agenda
In
a small community the planners and the people they are planning for are
close enough to share the same goals. In a large community the planners
are a small minority.